So I got an iPad…

30 May 2010, 9:26 am · 7 comments

… and seriously, how predictable is that? No comments from the peanut gallery, thank you.

My one line review of it is, it’s pretty awesome.

Having used it for about a week now, I really think that within a couple of years, devices like this will have made a big dent in use of traditional desktop and laptop computers. For an enormous number of tasks, it’s just a much better experience; the web feels really different when you access things by touching them and swiping them instead of manipulating things through a mouse or trackpad. Things feel more accessible. And of course the form factor of the device makes it ideal for reading web content in bed, on the couch, in a comfy chair, etc.

The laptop is a kluge – it’s not ideal for working at a desk, or anywhere else, but is highly portable and therefore very useful. Suddenly it feels a lot less useful.

Things I’ll ding the iPad for:

  • It’s a touch too heavy. Just a touch.
  • The screen is a finger-juice collector. A good cloth is a required accessory.
  • The touch-screen keyboard is a hundred times better than you think it would be, which means, not great for seriously writing things. I think my bluetooth keyboard will be a very handy accessory.
  • iPhone apps run on it, but they look like crap; you either get a little iPhone sized app floating in the middle of the iPad screen, or you can blow it up and get a pixilated version that looks horrible. Keeping track of iPad vs iPhone applications in iTunes is cumbersome; some seem to have both included in one app, which is much, much better.

As many of you know I am also a big fan of the Kindle and a lot of tech media has, rather predictably, talked about an iPad vs Kindle deathmatch. I am in the middle of reading a book* on the iPad – I decided to read the whole thing on the iPad to see what it was like. (I’m using the Kindle for iPad application.)

Because the iPad is a little bigger and noticably heavier, I have to kind of balance it on my belly to read in bed. (Good thing I’m not skinny.) It’s bright, which means I was able to lie on the bed and read with no lights while I had no electricity for 24 hours (don’t ask) and the battery life, while no match for a Kindle’s, is excellent. But that bright screen does wear your eyes out a bit faster than the Kindle’s; not a big deal if you spend 30 minutes or so reading, for a lazy weekend reading marathon (one of life’s great pleasures), I think the Kindle is a better bet.

But… it’s truly gorgeous. Everything is amazingly crisp, and any photos or illustrations – which just look bad on the Kindle – are really lovely. And, turning pages with a quick stroke of the screen is much easier than the Kindle’s page buttons.

So I’m not trading in the Kindle, but I suspect I’ll be reading more on the iPad than I expected to, and if I were going away for the weekend, I’d probably just bring the iPad in lieu of a laptop and the Kindle.

So it’s got some v1.0 issues, but – as they so often do – I think Apple has finally gotten something right that everybody else has been getting wrong. Which is a good thing, as I expect it won’t be long until there are iPad-ish devices based on Android and other OSs in common use. Even if you never use the Apple version, you can thank them for it.

* The book is Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter, a faux-history novel, and it’s quite good.

{ 5 comments }

Bob Hawkins May 30, 2010 at 9:33 am

I am a huge Apple fan and know that the iPad is the best thing since sliced bread. I now use it more than my desktop or my laptop but for reading books the Kindle is the better of the two. It is lighter and the screen is much better on the eyes.

laanba May 30, 2010 at 11:24 am

Congratulations! I can’t wait to get one, but it WILL have to wait probably until version 2. I can’t afford one right now and by the time I can I think version 2 will be a few months away.

The thing that is going to change for me is my next computer purchase past an iPad. For a few years now I said I was never going back to a desktop. Why would I need that big clunky thing? But I know that most of the things I use the computer for can be done on the iPad except for photo editing. And if I am only going to buy one thing I think I may end up buying a desktop instead because it will be very nice to have a nice large screen instead of the small laptop one (I can only afford one or the other). The iPad is going to be my mobile computing device. Interesting times ahead indeed.

Apanha M. May 30, 2010 at 4:23 pm

Dear John,

I’m sorry to hear that you consider the content at MediaPoint as an infringement.

As a matter of fact it’s only an excerpt from your post “SO I GOT AN IPAD…”

And, BTW, there is propper attribution as there’s a link to your site after the small piece of text.

Take a look at the post:

SO I GOT AN IPAD…
As many of you know I am also a big fan of the Kindle and a lot of tech media has, rather predictably, talked about an iPad vs Kindle deathmatch. I am in the middle of reading a book * on the iPad – I decided to read the whole thing on …
View original post here:
So I got an iPad…

However, as you want it removed I will do it in order for your stress levels to go down.

Thanks for letting me know and wish you the best!

AM

David B. May 31, 2010 at 11:37 am

I mine. Any notion of buying a personal laptop went out the window. I hardly use my MB Pro at work since getting it, unless I’m delivering presentations because I don’t want to spend the money to buy Keynote and that VGA thingie for work stuff, and our presentations are enormous courseware PPT decks and crash the desktop version of Keynote anyway. But for email and whatnot, it’s replaced the laptop and works fine with MS Exchange and my colleagues are all squee-y about it. One of my students uses six or so in his shop for order entry, tracking, etc. using a web front end on Filemaker Pro.

As for fingerprints, you can get anti-smudge -glare screen films for not very much. I ordered some from amazon and it was pretty easy to apply without any bubbles.

david B. May 31, 2010 at 11:38 am

Um, no angle brackets, Wordpress? Guess I should have escaped them: “I <heart> mine.”

Comments on this entry are closed.

{ 2 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: